with all due respect I didn't establish that he was an upgrade. I simply asked the question. My view is that we should be getting major upgrades when we get players and not going for like for like if we are looking to move up the table. Also, the comment I replied to suggested that he 'could' be an upgrade. If there is that much ambiguity about whether is in an upgrade or not then I would prefer to steer clear. That said, I know very little about the guy, fortunately it will be up to Gerrard et al to make a decision