He did come with a rep, and yes he was poor and didn't live up to it.
Steer isn't better than him for me though. Not at coming for, or catching crosses. He looks panicked a lot under crosses and was often shaky at corners.
Those two catches at the end of the play-off final were wonderful though yes. Second one was celebrated like a goal around me. He didn't come charging out to claim them though, they were floated crosses into his six yard box he should have been catching.