Neither really. He is a top player. But his defining attribute is his creativity when given license to roam. Pep is a great manager, but he insists on coaching positioning to the nearest yard. That's fine, it works, but we all saw that in such a system the quintessential Jack would be taken out of him. I just cannot see why Jack did not see it himself if we all could.
Massive waste of a career. Could have been the next Gazza, now the next Ravel Morrison.
I just hope he does a Merson, and moves on to a team where they just let him do his thing. Hope it's not us though.