This is Madrid we're talking about though, with the best player in World football.
As oppose to Barca with the other worlds best player It's dangerous play precisely because he doesn't know the guy is there.
I don't get how people don't understand this. Watching the ball doesn't mean you can start kung fu kicking across the pitch. You're responsible for where your feet end up, and not watching where you're launching a high boot into is by definition reckless play, and therefore a red card is entirely appropriate for it.>
Exactly
No, not correct. Every single game would be filled with red cards if that was the case.
Imagine a bicycle-kick inside the penalty area. How many times have you seen a player trying to score a goal (which is basically the same as Nani in terms of NOT trying to hit the other player, but scoring or bringing the ball down in this case) - then hit another player in the shoulder instead and get red-carded for the offence? I have seen thousands of matches and I cannot remember many red cards for such an action, even though there are many players around him when he does it. Is there a difference between what Nani did tonight and a striker trying to score a goal from a bycicle-kick? Not really, just because the foot hits the chest or whatever does not mean much when the offensive player is obviously not trying to harm the other one.
Common sense guys, this was not a red card.
I have seen lots of free kicks given for Bicycle kick attemtps. Think Crouch gave one away the other day? But yeah, as Zatman says - Not 6 studs planted into the body of an opponent.
Yes of course free-kicks are given, but not red cards. Because the player is clumsy, not actively trying to hurt the other one, even though he hit him in the face or shoulder with his boots, studs or whatever.
My point is that people are making no exception for when a player tackles viciously or when he is just unlucky. There is common sense in the middle, and that's why the great refs manage to see the important differences and that's why the best ones get to ref the final. This one is obviously not going to be given that match for this obvious mistake.
But common sense isnt in the rule book. It was common sense that kept Nemanja Vidic on the field in the League cup final.
Actually it was fear that the ref would offend Fergie